Chapter One
The Nature of Cultural Geography

Lecture and Discussion Outline

 

Definition and Historic Development of Geography

“Earth Description”

Environmental determinism

Areal differentiation

Quantitative revolution

Post-1970

Unfortunately, school geography has never evolved much beyond “place name geography” in the United States.

What is Geography?

According to the text:
“the science of place”

Is an art as well

Like history, but geographers study phenomena primarily through the lens of space, and secondarily through the lens of time.

Maps

GIS

What is Geography?

Geography is what geographers do

Geography is a discipline whose practitioners privilege questions of space as they seek understanding.

Geography answers “Why?” by asking “Where?”

Four Ws and four Ps

What--phenomenon

Why--process

Where--pattern

When--period

What Is Cultural Geography?

What is culture?

“Learned collective behavior”

Cultural geography is the study of spatial variation and spatial patterns of these behaviors

What is the interaction with the physical environment?

No easy explanation for phenomena

How the Text Is Organized

Each chapter revolves around a topic such as, agriculture, politics, religion, etc.

Each topic is covered by reference to five themes:

Culture region:  where is it?

Cultural diffusion:  how’d it get there?

Cultural ecology: how’s it linked to the environment?

Cultural integration: how does it interact with other cultural elements?

Cultural landscape: what does it look like?

Culture Region

Culture region: a geographical unit based on human traits

Three Types:

Formal

Functional

Vernacular

Formal culture regions

Area that people have one or more common traits

Core/periphery pattern

Corn belt

Bible belt

German speaking region

Formal Region: Diagram

figure

Formal Region: German Speakers

figure

Formal Region: Rural America

figure

Functional culture regions

A region that functions politically, economically or socially.

It has defined nodes and borders

Pizza hut delivery

The LA Times

The San Fernando Diocese

New Jersey

Functional and Formal Regions

figure

Functional / Formal Region: Germany

Vernacular culture regions

A region perceived to exist by people living within it, or by outsiders.

An outgrowth of a sense of belonging

Probably an outgrowth of a need to exclude others as well.

Powerful emotionally

Hard to characterize systematically

Vernacular Region: Dixie

Figure

Vernacular Region: The Midwest

figure

Vernacular Region: The Midwest

figure

Vernacular Region: The Midwest

figure

Vernacular Region: The Midwest

figure

Cultural Diffusion

Definition: spatial spread of learned ideas, innovations and attitudes

Sometimes an idea has a single hearth, others multiple hearths develop independently

Various types of diffusion patterns:

Relocation

Expansion

Relocation diffusion

Ideas move with people

Expansion Diffusion

Ideas spread, people stay put.

Hierarchical

Contagious

Neighborhood effect

Stimulus diffusion

Occurs when an components of an idea is accepted, but later modified to fit local needs.

Three stages

Impediments to Diffusion

Time-distance decay

Absorbing barrier (lousy term)

Barriers that prevent diffusion at some border

Border of Texas is an absorbing barrier for ____?

Permeable barrier

Permit only partial acceptance of an innovation or practice.

Liquor laws in the South

Susceptibility

Since many places have accessibility to new ideas and practices, why is it that everyone, everywhere does not behave and think identically?

We must be able to contextualize the acceptance or rejection of new knowledges.

Diffusion Diagram

figure

Diffusion Diagram

Figure showing the invention and diffusion of the printing press in Europe

Distance Decay

Confusing diagram depicting the distance decay of as innovations are accepted through time/space.  Core development at the top (greater availability of innovations in single location)

Cultural Ecology

Definition: cause-and-effect interplay between people and environment

Culture can be thought of as the way people adapt to the environment

Cultural ecology is the meeting ground of human and physical geographers

Cultural adaptation

Adaptive strategy

Four Schools of Cultural Ecology

Environmental Determinism

Possibilism

Environmental perception

Humans as modifiers of the earth

Environmental Determinism

Flawed notion that culture is a direct response to the dictates of climate and topography.

Popular during the 1800s-1920s.

Has some ugly potentialities and undermined the success of Geography as a discipline.

Environmental Possibilism

People are the primary architects of culture, although the environment gives us options that we may choose to follow or ignore.

Environmental Possibilism

figure

Environmental Possibilism

figure

Environmental Perception

This school argues that perception of the environment is most important. 

Ignorance is as important as knowledge

Geomancy or Feng Shui

Natural hazards and hazard zones

Hazard Location

Figure

Hazard Location: Malibu

figure

Humans as modifiers of the earth

Opposite of environmental determinism.

Argue that it is humans that are in the drivers seat in this relationship.

Earth Modification

figure

Cultural Integration

Cultures are complex wholes

Cultures are integrated systems

Each cultural aspect is dependent on others

Example: religion and politics and economics and race and …

Cultural determinism is a danger

Social Science

Scientific method applied to people

Laws are sought which explain humans spatial behavior

According to the text, space (geometric space) is a key concept in this modernist approach.

Model building is common

Economic determinism is a danger

Some progress made in accounting for geographic variation.

Humanistic geography

Place and place meaning

Humanistic views and subjectivity

Chaos Reigns

Postmodernism

Multiple definitions of postmodernism

Critical Theory and Cultural Studies

Cultural Landscape

The built and humanized landscape

Landscapes tell of the culture

Can be “read” like a text

Three principal aspects of cultural landscape

Settlement patterns

Land-division patterns

Architecture

Landscape

Consider the parking structure across from Sierra Hall.  What does it suggest about the culture that built it?

What symbolic values does it have?

What is not said?

Conclusion

Example: the American log house