Case Study: Keyboard Training and Hotkey Macros Quadruple Productivity
Cantor Access Inc.
Day Phone: 416-406-5098
This case study describes how training on keyboard access to Windows and hotkey macros enabled an employee with cerebral palsy to perform a complex task four times faster by keyboard than when using a combination of a keyboard, a mouse, and MouseKeys. She was able to complete a task that had previously taken over an hour in 16 minutes.
her previous job, using a mouse resulted in painful back spasms that caused her
to miss work. The spasms began to abate during this training program; six weeks
later, she reported that the spasms were much less of a problem.
the cost to accommodate this employee was significant, her improved
productivity should result in cost recovery within four months.
Joan’s disability is cerebral palsy. She has good control over her left arm, but moves it slowly within a slightly restricted range of motion. She types with her left index finger and thumb. With her right arm, she has slightly less control and range of motion than with her left. Although she can type with her right hand, she prefers net to. Her speech is only slightly affected; she speaks clearly but somewhat slowly. Joan uses a powered wheelchair for mobility.
many years Joan worked in a call center. She later transferred to another
department to work as an operational support person in a “paperless” office.
Joan verifies scanned documents against information stored in databases; issues certificates; and prepares correspondence.
To facilitate the comparing of documents, Joan and her coworkers have side-by-side monitors. The two monitors function as a single desktop; employees routinely drag documents from one monitor to the other, and resize documents to fit the screen. They use seven Windows-based applications, four of which were developed in-house.
FACTORS AFFECTING JOB PERFORMANCE
1. Software problems
The four proprietary applications were not designed with accessibility or usability in mind. Screens tend to be visually busy, keyboard support is spotty, and functional irregularities are common.
Joan accesses her PC with a Cherry mini-keyboard and numeric keypad (G84-4l00 and 4700). She places the keypad to the left of the keyboard to give her easy access to Enter, Backspace, arrow keys, and MouseKeys. When the workstation is set up properly and she uses both hands, Joan can reach all areas of the keyboard and keypad without undue strain.
uses a regular mouse. She formerly used MouseKeys, but found them frustrating.
However, she still uses MouseKeys to drag-lock and double click.
She is not a good candidate for a trackball or touchpad.
a mouse and MouseKeys slow her down considerably. Although she can click on a
button in five to twenty seconds, there are many tasks--especially those that
involve dragging--that can take several minutes. Sometimes she does not even
complete these tasks.) Many of these complex tasks can be completed by pressing
a sequence of two or three keys on the keyboard.)
addition to contributing to inefficiency, Joan experiences painful back spasms
from using a regular mouse. In her previous job, she missed work due to
mouse-induced pain. Because her range of motion is limited, she cannot maintain
neutral working postures when accessing a mini-keyboard, keypad, and mouse. The
three devices take up too much space.
Joan appears to be of above average intelligence, but may have learning disabilities that she does not know about or has not disclosed. Her time management and organizational skills are not strong; she prefers to move the mouse cursor to a target in vertical and horizontal steps rather than the shortest (diagonal) path; and she has difficulties applying computer skills learned in one context to another. Although she is smart, she is smart, she is not especially technically—inclined.
struggles hard to learn new software. She tends to learn computer skills by
rote. She internalizes sequences of steps by performing them repeatedly, but
does not always understand (at least initially) why they work, or what to do if
the steps fail to produce the desired result.
Joan’s computer skills were lacking when I began working with her. For example, she did not know about right-clicking; did not always know when to click and when to double click; did not realize that Windows has two different cursors (the insertion point and mouse pointer); and did not know how to use MouseKeys effectively.
Over a two-week period, I developed macros for Joan and provided her with training/coaching. (These measures were part of a complex accommodation that included building modifications, work area reorganizations, telephone modifications, ergonomic adjustments, and speech recognition training.)
Joan and I met nine times over a ten-day period for two-to five-hour training sessions. The training focused on keyboard techniques, but also included basic Windows and MouseKeys concepts and skills. My approach to keyboard access was to introduce general techniques rather than to have her memorize hotkeys. These techniques included working with menus, navigating to controls, task switching, discovering shortcuts, and using macros.
I developed 17 Macro Express macros to launch applications, workaround inconsistencies, and simplify multi-step procedures. I concentrated on tasks that Joan performed with difficulty. For example:
* Joan needs to move documents from monitor to monitor. Solution: A hotkey macro to move the window that has focus to the other monitor, and resize it to fit the screen.
* When reviewing scanned documents, Joan struggled to click on two small “zoom” buttons. Solution: Two application—specific hotkey macros that click on the appropriate buttons.
* In the same application, scrolling can only be done by pointing-and-clicking. Solution: Six application-specific hotkey macros: The four arrow keys scroll vertically and horizontally, and PgUp and PgDown go to the previous and next page.
* The software developers accidentally used “T” as an accelerator twice on a screen. Pressing Alt + T activated the “wrong” command. Solution: A window—specific macro activated by Alt + T that sends keystrokes to trigger the correct command.
Joan often “loses” the mouse pointer, and spends time trying to find it. Solution: A hotkey that moves the mouse pointer to a particular spot on the screen.
After about 30 contact hours, Joan was using 10 or 12 of the macros. She was much less reliant on the mouse; but when keyboard access was impractical or impossible, she was more likely to use MouseKeys than reach for the mouse. She also decided to try using her right hand for the directional keys on the right side of the keyboard.
back spasms began to abate immediately. Six weeks later, she reported that the
spasms were much less of a problem.
As she began to internalize new techniques and work habits, her productivity quadrupled:
completed a task that initially took her over an hour in 16 minutes. With
practice, she may shave four to six minutes from this time. Experienced
co-workers without disabilities perform the same task in about five minutes.
Joan’s supervisor recognizes that Joan cannot work as quickly as her
co—workers, but is not overly concerned. He is obligated to meet production goals
and to accommodate employees with disabilities to the point of undue hardship.
Joan’s accommodations do not cause undue hardship.
The cost to develop the macros and train Joan was approximately $4000.
Assuming that these accommodations increase the monetary value of her work by $50 per day, they will pay for themselves in four months.